This transcript is auto-generated and may contain errors.
0:01 We say good morning. 0:02 Good morning. It is a to be learning with all of you. 0:04 I'm sorry that I'm not there in person, but at least the opportunity to learn together virtually. 0:08 A very special thank you to Mishi and to Jeremy who really works so hard to allow me to continue to give Shir even when I'm not with you in person. 0:17 Um I'm going to post all of the sponsorship information in the Dafomi WhatsApp group in the chat as well as on the podcast. 0:26 But a special thank you again to all of our sponsors for dedicating and sponsoring this year. 0:31 Say let us begin. 0:32 So today's pay 89. 0:33 We are picking up on 88b. 0:38 We actually left off three lines up from the bottom a little bit a little bit in the middle of a thought. 0:43 So if you remember again said so beautifully before that in the in the saying that was given two mitzvah. 0:51 the mitzvah of paradum the offer of paradum or say the ash of paradum and the of the but why not say that maybe part of the reward for his self- aacing humble behavior was that ultimately went ahead and got the 1:11 mitzvah of right the dirt because remember again the the blood is covered with with dirt so or with earth so maybe again it's also referenced is reference to himself as to which the here's the difference is what we call in 1:31 other words is not necessary for even if you didn't even if you didn't do the meat is still permitted for consumption as such the calls it a gimra calls it almost like a ha usually means like a preparatory act but 1:47 in this case it almost means like an ancillary like a secondary type of act. 1:51 So because it's not a primary mitzvah performance or for that matter again it's not so therefore it doesn't make it to this list as opposed to let's say the ashuma where you need that in order to become or by you 2:04 need that for the resol for the resolution of that doubt regarding immorality doesn't have that same that same oomph that same power to it is quite beautiful and rashi says mystery Even without covering the blood, the meat would have been 2:23 permitted. With the ashes of there is there is benefit. 2:29 Why? Because it purifies you. 2:32 Without the ashes, there's no offer. 2:38 And again, the the the dirt, the mixture of the hopefully creates or restores peace between husband and wife after getting resolution over what exactly occurred. 2:49 Incredible. Rabbit says as follows in the merit said top of pay test 89a remember again just a bit of context after gets involved in the war of the four kings against the five he rescues his nephew lot and he comes 3:09 before the king of stone and he's ready to go ahead and return all of the property he's ready to return all of the people that he rescued and the king of stone of course offers to go ahead and Au an 3:20 incredible reward for everything that he's done. 3:23 Says no thank you. 3:24 And the expression that he uses is I won't take anything from you from like a literally a string a string to the strap that is used to tie the shoes. 3:34 I don't want anything from you. 3:36 So the says in the in the merit why now the logic is because the end of the says that ultimately again knew that he was promised material wealth. 3:47 He was promised from he didn't want anyone to think that maybe his material wealth came from the king of stone. 3:54 As such he refused the gifts. 3:55 He said no thank you. 3:56 No one should think that it was the king of stone who enriched. 4:00 So in the merit of refusing this gift from the king of stone his children married to the blue string of and the strap of so a little bit of like a play on words right so says I don't want a 4:21 string so he refused the string therefore his children got the the string of which means they got the and because Now means the strap for the shoe. 4:32 We got the strap of soil. 4:37 So now so what is understanding over here is exhibited this tremendous amun because remember think about this like here did something very heroic not not not for any type of reward but here the king of stone is willing to reward 4:51 him financially. Everybody likes money. 4:54 So it's pretty amazing what that he refuses it but he doesn't refuse it because he doesn't like money. 5:00 He refuses it because he wants his financial enrichment to come from not from man. 5:07 So in the merit that he refused it his children get these two mitzvah. 5:10 So the says okay I understand I understand what does the say the says the nations of the world will see that the name of God is upon you now when do the nations of the world see that the name of 5:30 God is upon us that's this refers to the shro that when aid is so beautiful when a Jew wears his fill And again the nations of the world see that is the name of that is upon us. 5:46 Such a beautiful imagery within. 5:48 So if you look at is the ultimate almost like demonstrative sign that rests his name literally again on our heads. 6:04 So, so again, so I understand he wanted to make a kdeshm because he wanted to show that his wealth is not coming from the king of stone that is coming from hem. 6:14 So therefore because therefore we get to make a keshm also by literally wearing so to speak on our head that the nations of the world see that literally rests upon us. 6:24 But what is this? 6:26 What is what does that do? 6:26 The blue string mah is very beautiful says and again just want to point out this is a little this might sound a little bit familiar but in fact we saw like this but the version of actually is a little bit 6:40 different says why why is how is different than all the other colors which is another way of saying goes out of it way to say that you're supposed to dye one string of the is blue Why? 6:56 Why? Why blue? Why? 6:58 Why that color and not something else? 7:00 So the answers because the blue of the resembles the sea and ultimately the sea resembles the sky and the blue of the sky resembles the sapphire stone. 7:19 And somehow the sapphire stone resembles throne because the says whatever exactly this means but points out over here that ultimately the throne of has the appearance of sapphire. 7:43 So again, so reminds us of the sea. 7:46 The sea reminds us of the sky and the sky reminds us ultimately again of sapphire and sapphire reminds us of the Now it's interesting by the way the way Rashi understands us. 7:57 Look at Rashi. Rashi says remember which is the the animal which produces the D for comes from the sea right its blood is blue like the sea. 8:20 Therefore, good. So now it's beautiful. 8:27 But what does all this mean? 8:35 And when looks at his throne and he sees the bless of his throne which resembles the sapphire which resembles the heavens which resembles the sea which resembles the wear. 8:47 Hashem is reminded of our mitzvah. 8:50 What a beautiful and incredible idea. 8:52 Now how is this a little bit different than the version of because the classic understanding is like this that is there for us that remember again what ends up happening is I look at the it reminds me of the sea 9:03 the sea the sea reminds me of the raia the heavens the heavens remind me again of the kiaak but here the gimar as in sappir the the sapphire so normally we're focused on this that sitsus is there for the cultivation 9:15 of my and a recognition like we've spoken about so many times that proper and sustained spiritual growth is incremental. 9:23 Remember it could why don't you just say that reminds me of the throne of because that's not the way spiritual growth works. 9:29 Spiritual growth is staged and incremental. 9:31 That's how it's sustained. 9:32 So take it one step at a time. 9:34 We go again from the to the sea from the sea to the sky from the sky to the sapphire from the sapphire to the reminiscent of the famous says that dream when he had his first dramatic really first dramatic he 9:49 sees the ladim the angels of going up and ask why why a ladder why not a staircase to heaven why not a staircase to heaven why a ladder to heaven why a ladder to heaven so ultimately says Because on a 10:04 staircase you can scale, you could take more than one step at a time on a ladder. 10:08 You can't take more than one rung at a time. 10:10 That spiritual growth is incremental. 10:11 And again, sometimes this is difficult for us because we want to do so much. 10:14 We want to change so much and I want to be so much and I want to do it all now. 10:16 I want to do it all quickly. 10:18 No, it's not the way it works. 10:19 The beauty about one of the many beautiful is incredibly patient. 10:24 He's very patient and he doesn't need us to get to the top of the ladder now. 10:28 He just needs to know that we're trying to get one rung higher each and every day. 10:34 That's all. And therefore that's the essence of situs. 10:36 Now it's interesting is so on one hand sits is our vehicle of connection to but yet what Rash is saying over here is looks at his throne and he makes his way down. 10:47 Right? We use to make our way up. 10:49 Again I look at the reminds me of the sea. 10:52 The yam the yam reminds me of the raia. 10:54 The raka reminds me of the sappir. 10:56 The sappir reminds me of the covet. 10:58 So I'm using to work my way up to a kadesh that sees his throne, right? 11:04 It reminds him of the sappir, the sapphire. 11:07 The sapphire reminds him of the sky. 11:09 The sky reminds him of the sea and the sea reminds him of the so isn't how beautiful this is. 11:14 In this I am making my way to and is making his way to me. 11:22 This is the entire metaphor. 11:24 This is the entire metaphor of life. 11:28 We're always, you know, sometimes our relationship with is like two close friends who just want to spend time together, but for whatever the reason, they're just always missing each other, right? 11:43 Ruven comes to see Shim and just Shim's not home. 11:45 And Shim comes to see Ruin and Ruven's not home. 11:48 But the love is so intense and like all all they want all they want is to be together. 11:54 All the yid wants like we were learning in all I want out of life is to be close to and says my beautiful child all I want is to be close to you. 12:11 So I'm using the titus and I'm bringing my way up to that is looking at this and bringing his way down to my situs. 12:18 Right? So I start with myus. 12:19 I get to the kia. 12:20 Hashem starts with this kisak and it gets down to my situs. 12:25 But yet sometimes we just miss each other for whatever the reason. 12:30 We just I don't know we just we just don't connect. 12:32 I I come to him and maybe sometimes I feel like he's not home and he comes to me and sometimes he feels like I'm not home. 12:40 And so much of life, you know, it's almost so much of life is like how how could we connect? 12:48 How how could we finally spend some time together? 12:51 But how beautiful is it? 12:52 And this is true with all of but especially I'm using my to get to heaven and is using his to get to me. 13:00 I'm using my scissors to get to heaven and he's using his sus to get to me that the two beloved companions finally find each other. 13:18 This is very interesting. 13:19 So theft in general, the interesting thing about theft is theft is not obviously go on record with that. 13:25 But it's also because if you steal something, you could always return it. 13:29 However, if you steal something and you consume it, that's problematic. 13:34 Why? Because now I just don't have the ability to return it anymore. 13:39 So says that literally theft that is then consumed is very difficult because you can't return it. 13:46 And it's interesting. This is very interesting. 13:50 Returns everything to the king of stone. 13:52 But that which the soldiers ate, he wasn't going to return since that was already consumed. 13:58 There was no way for him to go ahead and return it. 14:01 It's incredible. There are certain things there are certain sunk costs in life that you can't get back. 14:06 Like what really whenever I see this camera what it reminds me so much in general is like time. 14:11 Time is that thing where if you use it up you can't get it back. 14:16 So we have to be so careful to use it in the right way. 14:18 There are other things that if you steal or you misappropriate or you misuse, you can make restitution. 14:24 You could give it back. 14:24 And then there are other things where if you just misappropriate it or you just steal it or you just misuse it, it's gone forever. 14:31 It can never be reclaimed. 14:32 How careful we have to be with that greatest resource of all time. 14:35 How we use this beautiful actually. 14:46 If you ever hear the son of quoted in a matter of literally again make your ears like a funnel such a beautiful expression in other words if you ever hear a quoted in the name of Rabi Alzar the son of 15:02 Lily listen up because it's going to be something good where do we get this from he quotes the so the says this is actually in this past week's paria There's quoted this by this says doesn't love us because we're great 15:25 in number. That's not he didn't choose us because we're the biggest nation because we're the mightiest nation. 15:31 So listen to this. 15:32 What does this mean? 15:34 Just by the way, I want to point out something amazing. 15:36 If you notice the says, it's not because of your great number from amongst all of the nations. 15:44 So we translate it as it's not because we're the greatest nation or or the greatest largest nation that Hashem loves us. 15:51 But the word kashak is so much more than love. 15:54 The word kashak is desire. 15:57 In fact could sometimes mean almost like almost like a carnal desire. 16:01 We see this by the war bride. 16:03 Right? The Torah says that's not love. 16:06 A Jew is not falling in love with this woman that he meets in battle. 16:09 That's desire. It's intense. 16:11 Sometimes, amazingly enough, desire could be even more intense than love. 16:17 And it's fascinating just to see how uses of by us, not to us, he also uses the word love, but he's trying to highlight this idea that doesn't just love us like he's crazy about us. 16:31 He's he's desirous of us. 16:33 It's incredible. I I desire you. 16:41 Why? What? What? What? 16:43 What is it that loves about us more than anything? 16:47 This is so beautiful. 16:53 Because even when I shower greatness upon you, you diminish yourself. 16:57 In other words, you exercise humility. 16:59 Even when I shower greatness upon you, you exercise humility. 17:03 For example, I gave greatness. 17:09 Right? To remember again was given many great in the beginning of I gave him all this great and what does he say? 17:16 I am but dust and ashes he gave greatness to and what do they say? 17:25 What are we say? 17:29 I'm like a worm and not even worthy of being called a man. 17:32 So again this idea that even when confers greatness upon us we are so humble. 17:38 Then this goes back to yesterday's daf where we learn this idea that the power of humility remember again what does humility do? 17:45 Humility gives you clarity. 17:48 So what does love more than anything he loves our humility because as you saw in yesterday's when you have humility you know what you are and I know what I'm not. 17:59 I know what I'm not. 17:59 I know what I know what I've accomplished. 18:01 I have to get myself a selfish guy for my accomplishments, but I also have to be ever aware of my deficiencies, what I have to work on. 18:06 I could tell the difference between and I can tell the difference between right and wrong. 18:12 Humility creates clarity. What does love most about us? 18:16 Our humility. However, contrast this. 18:20 The nations of the world does not like this. 18:23 How so? says, "I gave greatness to Nimrom. 18:30 I gave greatness to Nimro." 18:31 What did he built? 18:33 He built a tower in order to go ahead and rebel against me. 18:38 I gave greatness to parro also rebelled against me. 18:41 Who is God that I should listen to him? 18:48 Again, who is the great ruler of the Assyrian Empire? 18:51 He says, "Who is this God amongst the gods of the lands? 18:57 said, "I'm going to rule above the clouds." 19:01 The king of I have sat on the seat of God in the heart of the seas again. 19:08 So just contrasting gives greatness to the nations of the world and they become arrogant. 19:13 Hashem gives greatness to the Jewish people and the greatness al even with the greatness we still remain profoundly humble. 19:25 that which was stated by is even greater than that which was stated by how so it says I am but dust and ashes but it says and what are we so he said I'm dust and ashes dust and ashes is 19:46 still something still something were even greater they said what are we But what what what what are we even the world is only sustained because of the what this really means is that the world is sustained ultimately because of the 20:06 merit of those who exercise humility by says what are we that literally again the world is sus is sustained or I should say suspended is suspended or is held up ultimately by those who live a life of bi like what 20:27 are we what are we and again this goes back to our humility motif the world is sustained by humility because humility creates clarity and creity excuse me and that clarity allows me to ac work on the things that need to 20:41 be worked on accomplish the things that need to be accomplished build on my strengths and rectify my weaknesses first wide line says The world is only sustained by this is incredible by someone who muzzles himself. 21:00 Bowling means like to close your mouth. 21:02 Musles yourself at a time of at a time of fighting. 21:08 The world is suspended by those of a play on words. 21:16 So this is absolutely this is absolutely incredible, right? 21:20 We could all relate to this. 21:21 You get into it with someone, right? 21:23 And they say something ridiculous or they say something hurtful. 21:25 So, of course, the first reaction is I'm going to say something right back. 21:29 The ability to exercise that self-restraint and not to say something. 21:33 The ability to hold back and to muzzle yourself that sustains the world, which is another way of saying there are different traits which sustain the world. 21:40 What what does that mean when you hold yourself back? 21:43 That's self-restraint. That's self-restraint. 21:46 Self-restraint is the icker to being a successful Yid because what does demand of us self-restraint I I can't eat whatever I want I can't do whatever I want I can't wear whatever I want I can't live with whoever I want there 22:00 there are limitations there are limitations and sometimes the best way to work on your self-restraint is in your interpersonal interactions because inevitably well we all know not a day goes by that someone does not say something that you just want 22:14 to like punch him in the face, right? 22:18 Go ahead and tell him to be quiet. 22:19 A verbal, but not not a physical one, right? 22:21 A verbal one. But the ability to like [snorts] I don't have to respond. 22:26 I don't have to respond. 22:27 I have the co of self-restraint. 22:29 I have the ability to not just because you're asking and just because you're saying doesn't mean I have to respond. 22:36 I don't have to. 22:37 I could exercise restraint. 22:38 I could say again. 22:39 And it's interesting, right? 22:40 Because we think people go through life and they think that because someone is saying something, it requires a response. 22:48 Not true. Just because someone says something doesn't mean that I have to answer doesn't mean that anyone has to answer. 22:53 That ability to say, "Okay, good. 22:55 You can say whatever you want. 22:56 I don't have to respond. 22:57 I don't have to respond." 22:58 that that level of that level of self-restraint, that ability to go and hold yourself back even when you kiss because you just want to you want to you want to let it go at the end of the day. 23:08 That's what sustains the world. 23:10 Incredible humility sustains the world. 23:12 Self-restraint sustains the world. 23:15 Incredible. What sustains the world? 23:20 Someone who makes himself like nothing, which again, as we said on Sunday or Sunday, yeah, is is humility. 23:28 humility. So, we're back to the humility. 23:34 Literally, again, he is underneath the arms of the literally someone who puts him under someone who puts himself underneath the arms of the world. 23:41 He lowers himself. He humbles himself. 23:43 Such a person sustains the world. 23:49 Listen to how beautiful this is. 23:52 This says, What is the primary? 24:00 What is the primary purpose of a person in this world? 24:04 He should make himself like a mute. 24:07 Don't respond. Now, now what does that mean? 24:09 My in this world is not to respond. 24:11 No, but now I understand it. 24:13 Self-restraint. My aod in this world is self-restraint. 24:18 If I could exercise that ability and cultivate that ability, I will be ridiculously successful. 24:26 Torah, she might have felt maybe have to exercise self-restraint for spiritual pursuits as well. 24:32 No, speak righteousness. Just like don't hold yourself back from speaking Torah. 24:36 Hold yourself back from giving back a giving back a retort. 24:40 But when it comes to spirituality, don't restraint. 24:42 Let yourself go. And again, this is very important, right? 24:45 Because sometimes we we feel we have to exercise restraint in our and of course there is a place for restraint in everything. 24:51 But sometimes you just got to let your nishama fly. 24:53 You just got to let it go. 24:56 You might have thought ultimately again a person could become a arrogant because of their ultimately again says ultimately again make sure to make yourself like the plane just like the plane is flat that represents once again a sense of humility 25:17 say we begin to see over and over and over this beautiful motif that the two primary qualities that loves more than anything about us. 25:25 Number one, our humility because again, humility breeds and creates and engenders and allows and enables for clarity. 25:32 And number two, self-restraint because the ability to say no, to say no to myself, right? 25:38 The ability to say no. 25:39 I I I don't have to respond. 25:40 I don't have to act. 25:42 I don't have to react. 25:43 That is the almost like the gatekeeper mida for kadusha because without self-restraint, I can't I can't get anywhere. 25:51 Without self-restraint, I'm just going to be derailed by every desire and want and lust and proclivity. 25:57 But with self-restraint, there's no telling what I can accomplish. 25:59 Humility, self-restraint, that hashem loves more than anything about us and the very which sustain and uphold the entire world. 26:07 Incredible. All right, back to very interesting. 26:16 You can go ahead and cover blood with the blood with the dirt, excuse me, of is a condemned city. 26:23 A city in which the majority of the residents have worshiped idolatry. 26:27 You have to go ahead and you have to go ahead and essentially destroy the city. 26:32 We kill the inhabitants, destroy the city. 26:34 So says you could use the dirt of ultimately again to cover blood. 26:41 Now the reason why this is interesting is because is any of the property of the has to be destroyed. 26:46 You're not allowed to get any can't get any benefit from because it has almost like the identity of just one big. 26:57 So how can you use the dirt? 27:01 You can't get benefit from it. 27:04 No. No. What is it talking about? 27:05 It's talking about means the dirt of the dirt. 27:08 In other words, almost like the soil that hasn't been disturbed, the hard soil. 27:12 So that hard soil which again at the end of the day was not part of the active use of the city that you could use for very interesting boats because the says you shall take all of the all of the 27:26 possessions of the city gather it into the street and burn it. 27:30 What do you see from here? 27:34 This tells us that what what's destroyed only that which is which only requires gathering and burning but like the undisturbed soil like the virgin undisturbed soil ultimately again. 27:49 So that would require you know shoveling like uprooting and then gathering and then burning. 27:54 So only only the property in the city that just needs to be gathered and burned that's what you have to destroy but nothing else has to be destroyed. 28:01 Ra says No, says that's not a problem. 28:05 You could even use the dirt of why because that's not called, right? 28:10 Performance of is not called. 28:12 It's not called getting benefits. 28:13 Therefore, you could even use the dirt of as well. 28:18 So, the was sitting over saying over this ruling. 28:32 How credible is this? 28:34 ready. So let's say again you have you have a ram you went ahead and you have the chauffeur of that order just ultimately what's you cannot blow it you cannot use it for my doesn't it mean if you did blow 28:52 it you're not saying so see from here again this is a mitzvah and yet we see that a mitzvah is considered it's considered a benefit that's not what it means if you did you shouldn't blow it you shouldn't ideally don't 29:04 use it but if you did use it ultimately again your say right says you should not use you shouldn't use it incredible right we got we got now we got now we got lul doesn't mean if you did take it 29:26 you're not y see from here that again mitzvos are considered a form of no what it means is you shouldn't use it but if you did use your changes this reverses course. 29:40 It's not true. It's not true. 29:44 The explicitly says that if you take the chauffeur of or the you are not you're not which would seem to indicate to us that performance of is a form of and since I can't get from the zor I can't use 30:01 these items. 89. Oh, here's the difference. 30:12 Here's the reason why you can't use the chauffeur or you can't use the lul love of. 30:18 And the reason is because both chauffeur and lul love have a there's a requisite amount. 30:24 says over listen to this is a shear you have to be able to hold it and there has to be some chauffeur extending on each side is now when you have a chauffeur of in if it's already been crushed and 30:53 destroyed Rashi says over here since is fit to be destroyed is anything that is fit to be destroyed is as if it's already been destroyed and therefore the problem with using the lul or the chauffeur is that it lacks the 31:13 requisite shar that's it nothing to do with it's that it lacks the requisite share by the way you see this specifically since it is only to be destroyed it's as if it's already been destroyed. 31:25 Therefore, it doesn't have the because it doesn't have the therefore can't use it. 31:33 But again, remember that's the very thing that works good for because remember what do you need? 31:38 You need something crushed. 31:40 You need something destroyed, right? 31:41 You need you need you need it ground up into into dust. 31:43 So that's fine. Therefore again you could use the dirt of an but the chauffeur or the is not usable. 31:55 Why? Because it is as if they lack the requisite incredible. 32:05 We have now finished the par of Gadam and we now transition into the incredible par of Ghanosha. 32:11 I'm going to post um just the good image of the ganosh. 32:15 We're not we don't really need it today so much but just for future reference. 32:19 So ganosh remember again ganosha is the sciatic nerve of the animal is we do not eat the interestingly enough. 32:27 Interestingly enough so remember again this is actually fascinating. 32:29 Why don't we eat the gan? 32:31 So this references back to the story of where in parish where Yakovinu is getting ready to meet Asov on the night before that fateful encounter the Torah records a very strange story where Yakov Ainu wrestles with a mysterious ish mysterious 32:46 man. Rashi identifies according to Gimar identifies this mysterious ish as the saw Asa the ministering angel of As they fight until the morning and the ish realizes he cannot he cannot best Jacob. 32:57 So what does he do? 33:00 He injures him in the thigh. 33:02 He injures him on in the sciatic nerve. 33:04 And even though Jacobu again essentially wins the fight, he's left limping. 33:09 Therefore, the Torah says therefore should not eat the ganosha. 33:15 That's why I don't need to say interesting. 33:17 So there's a lot of lot of fascinating ideas about this but just and we'll get more into this into the parak but just for today's purposes kind of by way of hakama that brings down so beautifully that this entire episode 33:29 is a magnificent foreshadow to the entirety of Jewish history which is in Jewish destiny which is we fight we have enemies that come at us and our enemies hurt us our enemies hurt us and often at the at the end 33:42 of the day we're left limping the says we may be limping but we're always standing The yid that never buckles, the never bends, the never bows, and the yid never loses. 33:53 Again, we get hurt, we get broken, we get battered, and we are limping, but always standing. 33:59 And therefore, says don't eat the ganosha because I want you to remember, I want you to remember that at the end of the day in your personal lives and your national lives, yes, you will face challenges that will hurt you 34:09 and you will face challenges that may even break you and you will face challenges that can be overwhelmingly and exceedingly difficult. 34:15 But at the end of the day, you will always remain standing. 34:21 No is almost like the source of the greatest amount of confidence that we have in our lives as individuals in our existence ultimately again as a claw. 34:28 Again, more on that as we go through the paran. 34:32 So applies both as well as outside in the presence of outside of the presence of it applies both to as well as and it applies both as well as it applies again there's two satic nerves it applies both on the 34:57 right side as well as on the left side but it does not apply by birds. 35:02 Why? Because as you're going to see the sciatic nerve really is begins by the what called the rounded part of the hipbone. 35:10 So because a bird does not have that rounded hipbone therefore it has no gan and githan also applies by a fetus. 35:19 So again even though technically speaking as you saw by ben paka that if you shack the mother that takes care of the fetus but again the fetus still has the prohibition of githanosha. 35:30 So you cannot eat the even of a fetus and fetus itself might not require because it was permitted with the of the mother but the prohibition of still applies says disagrees. 35:44 He says no it does not apply to a fetus. 35:46 We saw this actually before because holds that when the fetus was permitted with the of the mother ultimately again the entire animal is permitted. 35:53 Again more on that later on. 35:56 However, again, as much as we say that the of the fetus is the of the fetus is okay. 36:05 Why that is, we'll have to see. 36:09 Interesting enough, the butchers are not believed to say that they removed the Now, why not? 36:15 Rashi says, "As you're going to see, the removal of the GI is very complicated. 36:23 you really have to get in there to remove the entire nerve. 36:27 So, unfortunately, the butchers are not believed. 36:29 They're not believed. They say they did it, but they didn't really do it. 36:34 Say no. The butchers are believed both for as well as for they are believed ultimately to say that they've removed these items. 36:43 Okay. There will a lot to unpack over here. 36:45 Here we go. Says the mdash. 36:48 So the Mishna said that the prohibition of applies to as well to which the says that's obvious the assumption over here is remember the prohibition of githanosha obviously precedes carbonic designation because from the moment that the animal is born or 37:07 according to some even when the animal is in utero there's a prohibition of gdanosha right the carbon designation doesn't come till later so of course what's the saying of course even if an animal is a carbon it's going to provision 37:20 What? What's the What do you think that the prohibition of goes away? 37:28 Of course not. Stain times. 37:31 You might like this. 37:32 So say we're going to see one of the overarching that we're going to be talking about is does a gid infuse flavor? 37:39 Does infuse flavor or not? 37:42 So maybe he'll say that and again we'll talk more about this. 37:44 Maybe we'll say that are no saint infuse flavor and maybe what we're saying is like this that the devolves upon the isra of g. 37:57 So if you eat the if you eat the ganosha ultimately again of a carbonic animal you're in violation of two number one and because it has flavor of meat ultimately you're also in violation of consumption of carbonic meat. 38:11 Maybe that's what they're saying. 38:12 If that's the case that it shouldn't say that the prohibition of g applies to carbanos rather it should say the prohibition of heish applies to gam rather what you have to say is that no perhaps again g doesn't have taste 38:29 now this is important because what that would mean is the prohibition of gan is to consume gana but if you consume gana it's not considered to be consumption of meat it's consumption of the gtoin is And therefore if you were 38:45 to eat illegally eat the githan of a carbonic animal, right? 38:50 You would be in violation of githan consumption but you would not be in violation of illegal consumption of carbonic meat. 38:58 Why? Because since the g does not have flavor, it doesn't have the status of meat. 39:04 It's interesting. So we're saying githanosha applies to carbonos. 39:07 If you eat the githanosha of a carbon, you're in violation of githanosha. 39:10 But let's say I don't know you eating a carbon outside of the mikdash are you eating outside of the prescribed time you would not be in violation for eating carbonic meat illegally. 39:18 Why? Because the g has no flavor. 39:21 This is very important. 39:21 So when we speak about this idea of does it have flavor not have flavor? 39:27 That's another way really of asking does the ga also have the designation and the status of meat. 39:36 Is that true that our holds that the g doesn't have flavor we learn if you cook the thigh of the animal with the in it if there's not enough meat to be the g i.e If the gid infuses taste then 39:53 the entire thigh is going to be. 39:55 So what do you see from here holds that does have the flavor of meat. 40:04 This is very interesting. 40:05 What are we talking about over here? 40:07 We're talking about over here where the carbonic animal gives birth to an animal and the holds that applies to a fetus. 40:22 and he also holds that the offspring of which are in already have sanctity and therefore so this is incredible and therefore again will say that the of the and ultimately again the of the oftish occur simultaneously so again there's a 40:44 lot there's a lot of ifs with this right if you hold that ultimately again a carbonic animal ultimately as sanctity within uro. 40:51 And if you hold that the prohibition of gid ultimately applies to a fetus as well, that would mean again that and carbonic sanctity devolve simultaneously ultimately upon the same animal and therefore it's possible if you were to then consume the 41:04 g that you would be in violation of both of these things. 41:07 So the says so again is you want to set this up as if he's dealing with a fetus since the said that also applies in a fetus we would assume that that that ultimately again it's that the racial the first 41:24 part of the is not talking about a fetus is what it means to say this matter ultimately again is a point of contention between Rabihuda and in other words whether or not the concept of ultimately again applies by not does 41:45 ultimately apply by a fetus fundament we're still a little bit kind of like in the middle of a thought but we'll stop over here for today beginning the journey continues tomorrow have a great
Expand transcript 6,413 words